niall_hearty2000 wrote:i think you are being overly critical on Kilduff last night. he got bugger all game time and he spun on a shot and it was deflected for a corner. was it McGrath that hit a shot straight at the keeper from a closer distance? little perspective guys. Killer probably isn't the answer but I think he is being singled out now. what did McMillan do tonight? he was absolute muck.
El Paso wrote:Kilduff scored the winner against Maccabi and the equaliser against AZ. For those goals alone I love him. I agree he doesn't offer enough but I don't like the way he's being singled out - he's not a one up front striker, which is what our system requires.
You have both suggested that he is being "singled out" implying that he is the only player to attract negative comments. That's simply not true.
Even if he were the only player to attract criticism, the valid question to my mind is whether any criticism is justified or not.
The main recent commentary in this thread has simply being an opinion that Kilduff is not the answer to our striking needs.
If anyone thinks otherwise, I would love to hear the argument